Religious belief tracks geography, not truth.

Question

Had you been born in Riyadh, you'd defend Islam with the same conviction you now defend Christianity. Lhasa, Buddhism. Ancient Athens, the Olympians. The overwhelming predictor of someone's "saving faith" is the latitude and longitude of their crib. A truth this important shouldn't depend on a postal code.

C.S. Lewis · Answer

The objection cuts both ways.

If geography decides religion, it also decides atheism. The modern Englishman who dismisses God was raised in a culture that taught him to. The Soviet child raised under militant atheism was no freer in his unbelief than the Tibetan child in his Buddhism. The argument, pressed honestly, dissolves every conviction anyone has ever held — including the conviction that geography decides convictions.

What the argument really shows is that humans receive their starting points from their cultures. This is true of mathematics, ethics, and language as well. It does not follow that there is no mathematics, no ethics, no truth in language. It follows only that we begin somewhere and must reason from there.

I was an atheist who became a Christian by argument and against my will. The accident-of-birth thesis cannot account for me, or for the Muslim who becomes Christian, or the Christian who becomes Buddhist. People do change.

Thomas Aquinas · Answer

God is not unjust to those who never heard.

The objection assumes that explicit Christian faith is the only path to God, and that those born outside earshot of the Gospel are damned by accident. The Church has never taught this. Those who through no fault of their own do not know Christ, but who seek God with a sincere heart and try to do his will as their conscience reveals it, may attain salvation.

What is universal is not the name of Christ but the natural law written on the heart, and the natural knowledge of God available to reason from creation. The Athenian and the Brahmin had access to these. Where they reasoned rightly toward the One, they reasoned toward the same God Christians worship — though they knew him imperfectly.

The accident of birth determines what one is taught. It does not determine what one is capable of knowing by the light of reason that every human shares.

Justin Martyr · Answer

The seeds of the Word were everywhere.

I was a Platonist before I was a Christian, and I do not repent of having read Plato. Whatever was said rightly by any thinker — Greek, barbarian, before Christ or after — belongs to us Christians. For the Word who became flesh in Jesus is the same Word who scattered seeds of truth throughout the human race from the beginning.

When Socrates spoke of justice, when the Stoics spoke of the Logos, when the Hindu sage groped toward Brahman — they were not all simply wrong. They were partial. They held fragments of the truth that came whole in Christ.

So the question is not "why was I born where I was?" but "what fragments did my tradition hold, and where do they point?" Every honest religion, examined closely, points beyond itself.

John Henry Newman · Answer

Probable arguments converge on certainty.

Belief is not arrived at by a single decisive proof, like a geometric demonstration. It is reached by the convergence of many independent probabilities — the testimony of conscience, the historical evidence for Christ, the witness of the saints, the experience of grace, the coherence of doctrine with what one already knows of the world. What I call the illative sense is the mind's capacity to weigh these together.

The accident-of-birth objection treats faith as if it were a coin flip — heads Christianity, tails Islam, decided by latitude. But a serious adult convert does not flip a coin. He weighs evidence, much of which his birth culture did not give him, and some of which it actively obscured.

That a child believes what he is told is not scandalous. It is how children learn anything at all. The question is what the adult does with the inheritance — examine it, or merely repeat it. Christianity, more than any rival, invites the examination.

Religious belief tracks geography, not truth.

The objection, in full

The objection cuts both ways.

Related objections